1936 New York Yankees
Most teams have a "That Guy", the person a team can't win the big one without him. It's not just a baseball concept. You think of Payton Manning, Tom Brady, Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant or Wayne Gretzky and know they're the key to the success for the Colts, Patriots, Bulls, Lakers or Oilers. We all know that most sports, especially baseball, are team oriented, but without the one guy it can be harder no matter what the supporting cast looked like. On the other hand, it sure helps to have another "That Guy" to pass the baton to like it seemed to be the case for the Yankees. The truth is, the only way to become "That Guy" is to win and prove the casual observers wrong.
Babe Ruth was without question "That Guy" and credited with putting the Yankees on the map with titles in 1923, '27, '28 and '32. In 1935, Ruth was out of New York and was retired by 1936, and the question for many fans was can the Yankees win without him. Lou Gehrig was an elite talent, but without a Ruth-less championship, he would never be known as another "That Guy". And it wasn't just for Gehrig to prove, the difference for the Yankees would fall in their ability to win without Ruth. A dynasty does not exist if it's only because of one man. It is a string of "That Guys".
In 1936, Joe McCarthy took his team to battle in search of that Ruth-less title. The American League pennant was no contest, as the Yankees blew away the competition, ending the season 19.5 games over the defending champion Tigers in 2nd place. What sure helped was that the Yankees didn't have just one "That Guy" leading them in Lou Gehrig, but they also now had a kid named DiMaggio.
The Giants were back in the World Series as well in '36 and there was a lot at stake in this series. Both teams entered this series tied with 4 titles each, the Giants still won more head-to-head WS matchups against the Yankees 2-1 and the Yankees had a record 12 game winning streak in the World Series on the line.
The Giants struck first in Game 1, winning the game and snapping the Yankees' historic streak. The Yankees, however, struck back hard, taking the next three games. The Giants forced a Game 6 and it was there that the Yankees poured on the runs and took the series with a 13-5 blowout victory. From here the New York Yankees as the world now knows them were born. 1936 was the first of 4 straight titles and the baton from Ruth to Gehrig to DiMaggio was established and wouldn't end there.
To the dismay of Yankee-Haters everywhere and in the future, the dynasty had begun.