2016 San Diego Padres
The high spending franchises get a bad wrap. Teams like the 2004 Red Sox or the 2024 Dodgers spent a fortune to bring in the players from outside the organization to win their titles. After their 90s dynasty, the Yankees opened up the checkbook instead of rebuilding to keep their title window open. If you want to win in baseball, a successful tactic is to spend money on the big free agent names. It's a good move, but by no means is it automatic playoffs just because you spend more money.
The San Diego Padres decided in 2015 that they were gonna spend the money and trade the prospects needed to compete for a title. And while that season didn't pan out very well, they doubled down in 2016. Among the finishing touches management felt needed to make this season a success was putting Andy Green in charge. Spirits and hype was high going into opening day...where they were destroyed in historic fashion by the Dodgers 15-0. Then they lost 3-0 and 7-0 to not only get swept in their opening series of the season against a division rival, but they got completely shut out in the entire series.
The season started off bad and only got worse. By the trade deadline, it was obvious the team wasn't destined for October despite all the prospects they traded away and money they spent to put this team together. It was time to blow it up and trade the expensive names off while promoting what few young talent remained to see if the future had any hope. Even their trades weren't without mockery, as the trade of Drew Pomeranz shed light on the shady practice of GM AJ Preller where he did not release accurate medical info to the league about his players. Preller was suspended and the team took yet another L over it.
The Padres limped to a 68-94 finish to come in dead last in the NL West, 23 games behind the Dodgers. They would proceed to post losing seasons until the 2020s, seeking to put this disastrous effort behind them and build again fresh.
The end of Shields in SD brought in a glimmer of future hope, though.